CNNMoney – ‘I was overpaid by Social Security’



Americans dealing with injuries, mental illnesses and other impairments are being notified out of the blue that they’ve been overpaid by the Social Security Administration and now owe thousands of dollars.

One 33-year-old veteran began receiving Social Security disability payments after his left foot was amputated following an explosion in Iraq in 2007. After going through rehab for his prosthetic leg, he began working full-time for a defense contractor in 2009. As soon as he started collecting a paycheck, the veteran, who asked to remain anonymous, reported his roughly $100,000 annual salary to the Social Security Administration.

Read the rest of the story at its source:

What is “Equipoise”?


Veterans often ask me what the term “equipoise” means. You will often see the term in decisions from the Board of Veterans Appeals (BVA) and the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (the CAVC, or Veteran’s Court). “Equipoise” is actually a word that is defined in the one of the federal statutes governing VA claims, 38 U.S.C. § 5107(b). It describes a presumption that the VA must give to the Veteran when the evidence on a given fact is evenly balanced (i.e., a 50/50 split proving one side or the other of a given fact).

The law states, “When there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence regarding any issue material to the determination of a matter, the Secretary shall give the benefit of the doubt to the claimant.” So, when the information in a veterans claim file is equal enough to either prove or disprove a particular fact, the Secretary is required by law to reach the conclusion which is more favorable to the Veteran. This does not mean that any evidence will put an issue into equipoise. On the contrary, equipoise only exists when there is equal evidence on either side of a particular issue.

For example, all things being equal, if two doctors each give differing opinions on medical nexus (connection of a disability to an in service event or injury), then the VA must conclude that the nexus exists in favor of service connection. Of course, the VA will often distinguish the doctors’ opinions, and try to show that the doctor who stated that there was no connection should be followed. This may be error, because the doctors may be equally credentialed, have both examined the Veteran and reviewed her or his entire claim file, therefore putting them more on equal footing than the VA claims.

The concept of equipoise can be a very powerful tool for Veterans to use in their claims for service connected compensation and pension with the Department of Veterans Affairs.

Demographics…..The simple, boring reason why disability insurance has exploded

Brad Plumer of the The Washington Post writes:  “There are now roughly 8.8 million Americans receiving disability benefits, a number that has doubled since 1995.

So what explains this rise? The radio segment explored several theories at length. One possibility is that the bad economy is to blame — it’s much harder for people to find work, so they go on disability. Another possibility is that doctors and applicants have conspired to game the system somehow. Or perhaps states are actively shunting workers onto disability as other safety-net programs vanish.”

But there might be a much, much simpler explanation: demographics. Kathy Ruffing of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities has argued that a huge chunk of the rise in disability since 1990 can be explained by the very boring fact that Americans are getting older:


Three big demographic factors are at work here…..”

For the rest of the story, read it at its source:


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 38 other followers